Can you judge these showas, please?

[BenDalat]

Good morning Koiphen family,

Can you judge these showa, please?
Are they females?

Thank you,

[Orlando]

Body lines look ok but the skin luster looks flat on all of the pictures, too me these are ones to hope they improve.

[BenDalat]

Thanks Orlando.

Is the skin luster depending on genetic or the environment?

Thanks again.

[Orlando]

Thanks Orlando.

Is the skin luster depending on genetic or the environment?

Thanks again.

I would say both but genetics would carry the larger percentage. A koi with great skin could be ruined in a substandard environment.

[coolwon]

2nd question, are they females?

Judging by the body shape directly from above,I would say males.

An angled side ways viewed picture, would be more telling.

Female fish tend to show a tummy taper, or slimming reduction just before the fishes vent.

[BenDalat]

I would say both but genetics would carry the larger percentage. A koi with great skin could be ruined in a substandard environment.

Thank you Orlando

[BenDalat]

2nd question, are they females?

Judging by the body shape directly from above,I would say males.

An angled side ways viewed picture, would be more telling.

Female fish tend to show a tummy taper, or slimming reduction just before the fishes vent.

Thank you Coolwon

[fly4koi]

I like the body, they are strong and should grow big, the patterns though they are okay, but again it depends on the price.

[BenDalat]

I like the body, they are strong and should grow big, the patterns though they are okay, but again it depends on the price.

Thanks fly4koi.
I hope the sumi will appear improve the patterns.

[fly4koi]

Thanks fly4koi.
I hope the sumi will appear improve the patterns.

Report back after a year, looking forward to it.

[BenDalat]

Report back after a year, looking forward to it.

I sure will.

[BenDalat]

After 4.5 months

[fly4koi]

Nice body, the black is coming in nicely on the right one.