Please judge my home breed

[a_21e]

Hi Everyone
Could you please judge my home breed the parents set are sakai ff
Unfortunately i lost her during the process.

https://youtu.be/TBXcpoLR9Zw
https://youtu.be/JVxDPQX8GSM

[coolwon]

Your Kohaku looks promising

[spkennyva]

Sorry to hear that you lost one of the parents!! I like the Kohaku. It is still developing and hopefully it will clean up a bit more as it grows - colors look good. The Sanke seems lacking in pattern and sumi. I could very well be wrong, but I don't believe that this fish will achieve the change required to make it a good Sanke. Thanks for sharing!

[Primitive]

How did you lose the parents to breeding?
Did you sedate and extract eggs?

[a_21e]

Your Kohaku looks promising

Thank you

[a_21e]

Thank you. I think so too, but i am still curious how its gonna turn up so i'll keep it for few more months. if nothing change i may have to rehome it.

[a_21e]

That is exactly what i did. I sedate her and extract the eggs and she was alright for few days in quarantine tank and passed away out of the blue. It was bad on my part since i did not really pay much attention to her after i extract the eggs. Well, i learned my lesson in expensive ways.

[lukef]

That bluetick Kohaku is a puzzle! I'd want to have a contest with it.... give everyone a koi outline and have them crayon-in the pattern it will have in 1,2, and 3 years from now.
Surely it can't hold that ticking???? Which way and where will it go!

[spkennyva]

I didn't mention previously, but you got really good growth. Can you share more about your methods, equipment, and particularly food?

[Matt24]

Sorry to hear that you lost one of the parents!! I like the Kohaku. It is still developing and hopefully it will clean up a bit more as it grows - colors look good. The Sanke seems lacking in pattern and sumi. I could very well be wrong, but I don't believe that this fish will achieve the change required to make it a good Sanke. Thanks for sharing!

This summarizes my thoughts as well. Thanks for posting these. I am likewise interested in the food and any thoughts on how you have gotten such good growth. I see that you are very near the equator. So I am sure the warm temperature year round helps with growth.

[SimonW]

Very nice! Though not the top quality still very good.

I just wonder from how many fry in the beginning you selected these two?